What Is Bear Steepening

The yield curve, a graphical representation of interest rates across different maturities, can provide valuable insights into market sentiment and economic prospects. One specific pattern, known as "bear steepening", is often viewed as a harbinger of economic weakness.

A bear steepening occurs when long-term interest rates climb faster than short-term rates. This pattern indicates that investors are worried about inflation and anticipate the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates in the future. This makes long-term bonds less appealing, as their fixed interest payments become less attractive compared to the prospect of higher future rates.

As a result, fixed-income investors tend to reduce their demand for these long-term bonds, leading to a decrease in their prices and a corresponding rise in their yields.

The key characteristics of a bear steepening are as follows:

• Widening Spread: A bear steepener is characterized by a widening of the spread between long-term and short-term interest rates. This means that long-term interest rates increase at a faster rate than short-term rates.
• Long-term Rates Rising Faster: Long-term interest rates rise faster than short-term rates, causing the yield curve to steepen. This can be driven by various factors such as inflation expectations, central bank policies, or market forces.
• Typically Bearish Market Environment: Bear steepenings often occur in a bearish market environment, where bond prices are falling and yields (interest rates) are rising, especially for long-term bonds.
• Inflation Expectations: Bear steepenings are often indicative of rising inflation expectations, which can lead to higher long-term interest rates as investors demand higher yields for long-term bonds.
• Impact on Bond Prices and Yields: As long-term interest rates rise, bond prices fall, and yields increase. This can lead to a bearish market for equities and potentially slow down investment and consumption due to higher borrowing costs.

How Does Bear Steepening Affect Investor Behavior

Bear steepening can significantly influence investor behavior in various ways, particularly within the fixed income and equity markets. Here's a breakdown of how it impacts different types of investors:

Fixed Income Investors:

• Shifting away from long-term bonds: Bear steepening suggests higher long-term interest rates in the future. This makes long-term bonds less attractive, as their fixed interest payments become less competitive compared to the potential for higher future yields. Investors may sell their long-term bonds to lock in current yields or shift towards shorter-term bonds with less interest rate risk.
• Seeking higher yields: Investors might seek out higher yields in other fixed income instruments, such as corporate bonds or emerging market debt, as these may offer better returns in a rising interest rate environment.
• Shorter duration strategies: Investors might adopt shorter-duration strategies, investing in bonds with shorter maturities that are less sensitive to interest rate changes. This helps mitigate losses in a rising interest rate environment.

Equity Investors:

• Growth vs. Value: Bear steepening can influence the preference for growth vs. value stocks. Higher interest rates can make growth stocks, which rely on future earnings, less attractive. Conversely, value stocks with strong dividends and earnings can become more appealing as they offer a more reliable return.
• Increased volatility: The uncertainty surrounding the economic outlook and potential for a recession can lead to higher volatility in equity markets. Investors may become more cautious and take on less risk, potentially leading to a pullback in stock prices.

Other Market Participants

• Borrowers: Businesses and individuals may face higher borrowing costs, potentially hindering investment and consumer spending.
• Central banks: Central banks may adjust monetary policy to address the economic outlook. They might slow down or even pause interest rate hikes if bear steepening signals a potential recession.

Generally speaking, bear steepening generally reflects a pessimistic economic outlook. It can lead to increased risk aversion, and investors may become more cautious and avoid riskier assets like equities. Investors might also seek out safe-haven assets such as government bonds or gold.

What Are Some Examples of Bear Steepening

Bear steepening is rare, and some reports indicated that there have only been 12 episodes in the past 50 years. Here are two examples:

1990-1991 Recession

The yield curve steepened dramatically in the lead-up to the 1990-1991 recession. Long-term interest rates climbed faster than short-term rates, signaling a looming economic downturn. This steepening occurred against a backdrop of a slowing U.S. economy, exacerbated by the Gulf War and rising inflation. The Federal Reserve attempted to curb inflation by raising short-term interest rates, but investors remained wary of the economic slowdown, keeping long-term rates relatively low. This widening gap between short- and long-term rates served as a powerful indicator of the impending recession, which officially began in July 1990. The recession lasted eight months, marked by declining GDP and rising unemployment.

2023 Inflationary Environment

The yield curve also exhibited bear steepening in 2023, with long-term interest rates climbing faster than short-term rates. This occurred during a period of persistent global inflation, fueled by supply chain disruptions and post-pandemic demand. To combat inflation, central banks, including the Federal Reserve, aggressively raised interest rates. However, despite recent signs of easing inflation, investors remain cautious about the resilience of price pressures. With medium-term inflation trends still firmly anchored and a robust economy, the Federal Reserve is unlikely to adopt a dovish stance, even if CPI data indicates a moderation in inflation. The Fed's commitment to maintaining a higher-for-longer interest rate policy was the main cause behind the steepening the yield curve, pushing long-term U.S. Treasury yields upward throughout the year. This bear steepening reflects the ongoing uncertainty surrounding the inflation outlook and the Fed's determined approach to controlling it.

Related Reading:

1. The Message From Bond Bear Steepening (Janus Henderson)
2. Bear steepening US yield curve dashes 'soft landing' hopes (Reuters)
3. What is Bull Steepening (Global Macro Playbook)

Back to our blog.