What Are the Lagging Economic Indicators

Lagging economic indicators are statistics that typically change after the economy as a whole does. These indicators confirm economic trends that have already been predicted by leading indicators or shown by coincident indicators. Some examples of lagging economic indicators include:

• Average Duration of Unemployment (inverted): This indicator reflects the average length of time individuals remain unemployed, which tends to increase after an economic downturn.
• Value of Outstanding Commercial and Industrial Loans: The value of outstanding loans in the commercial and industrial sectors can indicate economic activity and financial health, but changes in this value often lag behind broader economic shifts.
• Change in the Consumer Price Index for Services: Changes in the Consumer Price Index for services can reflect inflationary pressures in the economy, but these changes typically occur after broader economic movements.
• Change in Labor Cost per Unit of Output: This indicator measures changes in labor costs relative to output, providing insights into labor market conditions and productivity, but it tends to lag behind economic changes.
• Ratio of Manufacturing and Trade Inventories to Sales: This ratio reflects the relationship between inventories and sales in the manufacturing and trade sectors, with changes indicating shifts in demand and production levels, but these changes are observed after economic shifts have occurred.
• Ratio of Consumer Credit Outstanding to Personal Income: This ratio shows the level of consumer credit relative to personal income, providing insights into consumer borrowing behavior and financial health, but changes in this ratio typically lag behind economic trends.
• Average Prime Rate Charged by Banks: The average prime rate charged by banks reflects prevailing interest rates and credit conditions, but changes in this rate often follow broader economic movements.

What Are Some Limitations of Using Lagging Indicators in Economic Analysis

• Lack of Predictive Power: Lagging indicators provide information about the past and confirm trends that have already occurred, rather than predicting future economic conditions. They are not useful for forecasting or anticipating future economic changes, as they only reflect what has already happened.
• Delayed Signals: Lagging indicators change after the economy has already shifted, so the information they provide may be outdated or irrelevant by the time it is reported. This delay can make it difficult to make timely and informed decisions based on lagging indicators alone.
• Distortion and Influence by Other Factors: Lagging indicators can be influenced, delayed, or revised by other economic, political, or social factors, which can distort their accuracy and reliability. This makes it challenging to isolate the true impact of the lagging indicator on the overall economic situation.
• Limited Usefulness for Policymaking: Since lagging indicators confirm past trends rather than predict future ones, they have limited usefulness for policymakers who need to make decisions to influence the direction of the economy. Relying solely on lagging indicators can lead to reactive, rather than proactive, policy responses.
• Difficulty in Interpreting Trends: Interpreting the significance and implications of lagging indicators can be more complex than interpreting leading indicators, as they may not provide a clear or complete picture of the current economic conditions. Combining lagging indicators with other economic data and leading indicators is often necessary to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the economic landscape.

How Do Lagging Indicators Differ From Coincident Indicators

Lagging indicators differ from coincident indicators in the following ways:

• Timing: Coincident indicators change simultaneously with the overall economy, providing a real-time snapshot of current economic conditions. Lagging indicators, on the other hand, change after the economy has already started following a specific pattern or trend.
• Predictive Power: Coincident indicators have limited predictive power as they reflect the current state of the economy. Lagging indicators have even less predictive power as they confirm economic trends that have already occurred.
• Reliance on Historical Data: Lagging indicators are often backward-looking and rely on historical data to validate past economic trends. Coincident indicators use more current data to assess the present state of the economy.
• Examples: Examples of coincident indicators include industrial production, retail sales, and gross domestic product (GDP). Examples of lagging indicators include unemployment rates, inflation rates, and corporate profits.
• Usefulness: Coincident indicators are useful for monitoring current economic activity and providing a snapshot of the present economic conditions. Lagging indicators are useful for confirming economic trends that have already been predicted by leading indicators or shown by coincident indicators.

See Also:

1. US Jobs Growth Has Become a Lagging Indicator
2. The Yield Curve as a Leading Indicator

Back to our blog